š§ Can AI Consistently Beat the Market?
Insights from the Performance of AI in Long-Term Stock Picking
š§ Can AI Consistently Beat the Market?
Insights from the Performance of AI in Long-Term Stock Picking
I have been wondering recently if AI is so powerful, can we just leave our investment to it, and go to the beach? š
So I did some reseach, and below are some findings!
š Executive Summary
Can artificial intelligence (AI) consistently outperform the S&P 500 in long-term investing?
While backtests and certain platforms show promising results, consistent outperformance remains elusive in real-world settings. Still, AI has major upsideānot just in picking stocks, but in optimizing portfolios, managing risk, and enhancing investment research.
š Headline Stats: AI vs. S&P 500
For reference, below are some AI-modeled funds and how they compare to S&P 500.
*p.s. I will not take the numbers whole sale and jump right into it. These are the numbers they publish, but it will be difficult to actually verify the accuracies and any biases involved, if any.
Platform / Study | AI Performance | S&P 500 Benchmark | Time Period |
|---|---|---|---|
Zen Ratings (A-rated stocks) | 32.5% annualized | ~10ā11% annualized | Since 2003 |
Danelfin (AI strategy) | +191% cumulative | +118% cumulative | 2017ā2023 |
Chen & Ren (AI Mutual Funds) | Statistically similar to market | Market return | 2017ā2019 |
Eurekahedge AI Hedge Fund Index | +115% cumulative | +210% cumulative | 2011ā2020 |
Funds with High AI Hiring | +1.56% annualized excess return | N/A | Next 6 months |
ā” Verdict: A few stars shine bright, but most AI strategies havenāt reliably outpaced the market long-term.
š¤ Why AI Struggles (Sometimes)
Market Complexity: Black swan events and complex macro shifts make stock prediction hardāeven for AI.
Overfitting Risks: Models may learn patterns that donāt hold in the future.
Black Box Problem: Many AI systems lack explainability, hurting trust and transparency.
Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH): In theory, all known information is priced in, making consistent alpha tough.
š” Where AI Does Add Value
AI might not always pick the best stocksābut it shines in these areas:
ā Portfolio Optimization
Rebalance automatically, allocate efficiently, and reduce emotional decisions.
š Risk Management
AI spots hidden risks early by scanning massive datasets and running stress scenarios.
š° Trend & Sentiment Analysis
Natural Language Processing (NLP) helps AI decode news, social media, and earnings calls for real-time insights.
š Investment Research
AI accelerates analysis of financial reports, SEC filings, and data-heavy documentsācutting hours of manual work.
š ļø Tools for Retail Investors (Not recommendation)
Platform | AI Capabilities | Performance Highlight | Ideal User |
|---|---|---|---|
Zen Ratings | 115-factor stock grading, incl. AI metrics | A-rated stocks: +32.5%/yr since 2003 | Long-term investors |
Danelfin | Predictive AI Scores, best-stock models | +263% (2017ā2024) vs. S&P +189% | Active traders/investors |
TrendSpider | ML-enhanced technical analysis | Not specified | Technical traders |
Trade Ideas | AI scans for momentum trading setups | Not specified | Day traders |
Magnifi | Portfolio analysis & recommendation engine | Not specified | Beginners & casual users |
AIEQ ETF | AI-selected stock ETF | Underperformed S&P as of 2025 | Passive investors |
š§āāļø Don't Forget the Human Edge
AI is powerful, but it canāt replace:
Judgment during uncertainty
Contextual understanding of unique events
Empathy and trust in client relationships
Ethical oversight and decision-making
The future is hybrid: AI + Human Insight = Smarter investing.
š¬ Final Thoughts & Recommendations
Use AI to augment, not replace your strategy.
Critically evaluate AI platformsāespecially backtested claims.
Focus on AI for data processing, portfolio analytics, and alerts.
Maintain your personal investment edge: goals, risk appetite, and common sense.
AI is here to stay. But itās not your silver bullet - itās your super assistant.
Till next time!
Cheers,
Charlie
Enjoyed this issue?
Subscribe to get new insights delivered to your inbox.
Join the newsletter
Get insights on life's decisions, wisdom, and building your financial engine. Delivered to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.